Why Are You Paying So Much for Flood Insurance?
Could one document cut your premiums by 80%?
If you own a home in St. Louis and your flood insurance premiums feel painfully high, you're not imagining things. Living near the Mississippi or Missouri River often places you in a high-risk FEMA flood zone, regardless of your actual elevation.
But what if you could challenge that assumption, and win?
This article will show you how one investment, an Elevation Certificate, can cut thousands from your insurance bill starting this year. You’ll learn:
-
What an Elevation Certificate is and why it matters
-
How much it costs (and saves)
-
Real results from local homeowners
-
A step-by-step process to get one in St. Louis
Why Flood Insurance Costs So Much in St. Louis
St. Louis isn’t just near water, it’s surrounded by it. With both the Mississippi and Missouri Rivers bordering the metro, FEMA classifies much of the area as Zone AE, meaning high flood risk. If you live in this zone and have a mortgage backed by a federal lender, flood insurance isn’t optional, it’s required.
But here’s what most homeowners don’t know:
Without an Elevation Certificate, your insurance provider assumes your home sits at or below the base flood level, even if it doesn’t. That assumption can cost you thousands.
What Is an Elevation Certificate, and Why Should You Care?
An Elevation Certificate (EC) is a FEMA-standard document created by a licensed surveyor. It shows the height of your home relative to the Base Flood Elevation (BFE).
Here’s why that matters:
-
If your home is above the BFE, you represent less risk, and your premiums drop
-
If you don’t submit an EC, your insurer assumes the worst, that your home is at or below the BFE
That assumption can cost you big:
The average St. Louis flood insurance premium without an EC is $2,812 per year, nearly double the Missouri state average
St. Louis Homeowners Are Saving Thousands with Elevation Certificates
Real Results:
-
A south St. Louis homeowner reduced their premium from $3,000 to $350 per year
-
A family in Chesterfield dropped from $2,599 to $460 per year
That’s over $2,500 in yearly savings, often recouping the EC cost in Year 1
ROI Breakdown: Elevation Certificate vs. Overpaying for Flood Insurance
| Description | Without EC | With EC | Annual Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Avg Annual Premium | $2,812 | $350–$460 | $2,352–$2,462 |
| One-Time EC Investment | $0 | $650–$2,000 | Pays for itself Year 1 |
| 5-Year Projected Cost | $14,060 | ~$1,750 | Up to $12,310 saved |
How to Get an Elevation Certificate in St. Louis
1. Hire a Licensed Surveyor
Costs typically range from $650 to $2,000. We can connect you with professionals who specialize in flood zones.
2. Schedule a Site Visit
The surveyor collects elevation data on your home’s lowest floor, surrounding grade, and other benchmarks.
3. Receive Your Official Certificate
You'll get a standardized FEMA document that you own.
4. Submit to Your Insurance Provider
Your insurer uses this data to re-evaluate your risk and recalculate your premium.
The 2022 Wake-Up Call: Why You Can’t Ignore This Anymore
In July 2022, St. Louis was hit with nearly 9 inches of rain in 24 hours, triggering flash floods that devastated entire neighborhoods.
Flood insurance is no longer just a formality, it’s a financial survival tool. But that doesn’t mean you should overpay for it.
FAQs for St. Louis Homeowners
Q: Do I have to get an Elevation Certificate?
Not always. But if you’re in a Special Flood Hazard Area (SFHA), it’s the only way to prove your home may be lower risk than FEMA assumes.
Q: What’s the deal with FEMA’s Risk Rating 2.0?
This system uses more detailed data like elevation, proximity to water, and replacement costs. That means having an Elevation Certificate now has a much bigger impact on your premium
Q: Can I get an Elevation Certificate for an existing home?
Absolutely. In fact, older homes often sit higher than current maps show, which means a bigger potential savings through grandfathering
Real St. Louis Stories
“I wish I’d known about this two years ago. My policy dropped by over $2,000 after just one phone call”
— Local St. Louis homeowner
“The Flood Insurance Guru helped us get our Elevation Certificate and navigate Risk Rating 2.0, saved us $2,500 this year”
— Chesterfield homeowner
We’ve helped hundreds of Missouri homeowners uncover errors in flood zone assumptions and save thousands every year.
You’re Not Stuck with High Premiums
You now understand how a one-time investment in an Elevation Certificate could reduce your premiums by over 80%. If your home is in a FEMA high-risk zone, your insurance company may be assuming the worst. Start with a free policy review to see if an Elevation Certificate could save you thousands
At The Flood Insurance Guru, we specialize in helping homeowners challenge bad assumptions and make smart, cost-saving decisions.
